Anatoly Lubarsky Logo
programming, design, integration, games, music

Enterprise Library sucks big time

Somebody just has to put the facts on the table. This is what I think.


I have had much experience with Entlib from the times of separate "blocks" for Data Access and Logging. I had to use it because it was the policy. I want to make it brief and simple so here are my points:


  • Configuration and Deployment:
    • If you need an external WinForm application to be able configure this shit you are wrong wrong wrong...
    • 50k - 100k for Web.config is too much. Config file is not readable in notepad. Entlib 1 used to have multiple configuration files and one main config file that links to them. So you decide what sucks more...
    • Deployment and/or configuration of the working environment is a pain in the ass. What for do they need services or performance counters in case of class libraries. There is no need to take it that far.
  • DataAccess Block (aka DAAB).
    • Bugs in Enterprise Library Part 1 Bugs with data types (DataAccess block).
    • Bugs in Enterprise Library Part 2 Parameters sizes. This one is actually a design bug.
    • Performance sucks and it is not scalable enough. Writing custom Data Access block is not a rocket science and there are better libraries on the net. All over.
  • Logging block. It is a pain to configure. There are common libraries like log4net. If one has to put entry separators texts into the application configuration file there is definitely some design problem here. My advice - inherit from System.Diagnostics and keep it simple.
  • Exception handling block. I bet Exception handling block will dissapear in the future versions of Entlib. Exception handling is just policy, no need to make class library of it. You have just to decide regarding Exception handling policy. Simple points for exception handling policy:
    • Handle exceptions at a higher level, throw at lower APIs.
    • Do not swallow or downgrade (like returning boolean or error codes).
    • Log exceptions.
    • Do not use exceptions to define business logic flow.
    • For web - use in addition asp.net mechanisms.

These are main points. There are some other blocks like Caching and Cryptography but they are not so important. There are examples at Codeproject (and other sites) are more valuable, IMHO.


Related Posts:

Thursday, November 30, 2006 10:59 PM

Comments

# Interesting Finds: Week after Thanksgiving 4

12/1/2006 6:47 PM by Jason Haley

Login

Subscribe via RSS

Article Categories

.Net Framework
ASP.NET Tips
C# Win32 API
HTML, CSS, Web
Javascript Tips
MSSQL Tips
System
System.Net
WebServices

Archives

(02) January 2018
(01) June 2013
(03) March 2013
(02) February 2013
(01) July 2012
(01) April 2012
(01) September 2011
(01) August 2011
(03) May 2011
(01) December 2010
(01) November 2010
(01) October 2010
(01) June 2010
(01) May 2010
(02) March 2010
(01) January 2010
(02) December 2009
(03) September 2009
(03) August 2009
(09) July 2009
(04) June 2009
(03) May 2009
(02) April 2009
(03) March 2009
(02) February 2009
(02) January 2009
(04) December 2008
(04) November 2008
(05) October 2008
(04) September 2008
(05) August 2008
(04) July 2008
(05) June 2008
(07) May 2008
(04) April 2008
(03) March 2008
(02) February 2008
(03) January 2008
(03) December 2007
(05) November 2007
(04) October 2007
(05) September 2007
(12) August 2007
(11) July 2007
(14) June 2007
(13) May 2007
(13) April 2007
(10) March 2007
(11) February 2007
(14) January 2007
(14) December 2006
(12) November 2006
(08) October 2006
(09) September 2006
(06) August 2006
(08) July 2006
(10) June 2006
(09) May 2006
(22) April 2006
(25) March 2006
(12) February 2006
(14) January 2006
(19) December 2005
(17) November 2005
(16) October 2005
(16) September 2005
(12) August 2005
(14) July 2005
(09) June 2005
(12) May 2005
(12) April 2005
(20) March 2005
(11) February 2005
(12) January 2005
(18) December 2004
(13) November 2004
(12) October 2004
(14) September 2004
(09) August 2004
(23) July 2004
(19) June 2004
(29) May 2004
(19) April 2004
(16) March 2004
(09) February 2004
(06) January 2004
(02) December 2003
(01) November 2003

Post Categories

.Net and C#
Android
Antispam
App. Development
Architecture
ASP.NET
Blogging
Deprecated Projects
Facebook Platform
Fun
Google
iOS
Javascript
Misc.
MSSQL
Music
My Games
Performance
Roller
Social Networks
Tools
Visual Studio
Web 2.0
WebServices

About Me

linkedin Profile
Recs
Who am I

My Sites

Billy Beet
x2line blogs