Anatoly Lubarsky Logo
programming, design, integration, games, music

Primary Key best practices: INT identity vs. UniqueIdentifier (GUID)

I came over the forum discussion lately. Besides that I see more and more web engines implemented via UniqueIdentifier primary key (I guess), since I can see GUID inside the querystring (lame in my eyes), like in dasBlog.


So, what should I choose for my primary key ? Which datatype ? Personally, I like INT (IDENTITY). It is a small column (4 bytes with up to 2 billion), is useful for data warehousing (unlike natural keys), guarantees uniqueness, and is completely automated by the system. While you have to use 16 bytes for UniqueIdentifier.


Znichter has more:


"The GUID is a wide column (16 bytes to be specific) and contains a unique combination of 33 uppercase and numeric characters. This column because it is the primary key is going to be stored in, of course, the clustered index (unless specified to be a non-clustered index), and will be the page pointer for each leaf page in a non-clustered index. Also, if a GUID is used instead of an integer identity column then the 33 characters need to be matched for each row that is returned using that column in the where clause. If a high volume of inserts are done on these tables then GUID's being large will contribute to page splits, as will the fact that NEWID() generates a random value, which could place a new record on any of the data pages will cause performance problems."


And my 2 cents. Don't use GUID as PK (or at all) if you don't need to because:


  1. table row size limit in MSSQL
  2. storage + memory. Imagine you have tables with 10000000 rows and growing
  3. flexibility: there are T-SQL operators available for INT like >, <, =, etc...
  4. GUID is not optimized for ORDER BY/GROUP BY queries and for range queries in general


Update: here znichter posts part II on the GUID issue.


I have tested GUID selects months ago and can approve that queries perform just the same as with INTs if you work accurately. For GUID disadvantages see above.


Related Posts:

Friday, September 2, 2005 1:57 AM

Login

Subscribe via RSS

Article Categories

.Net Framework
ASP.NET Tips
C# Win32 API
HTML, CSS, Web
Javascript Tips
MSSQL Tips
System
System.Net
WebServices

Archives

(02) January 2018
(01) June 2013
(03) March 2013
(02) February 2013
(01) July 2012
(01) April 2012
(01) September 2011
(01) August 2011
(03) May 2011
(01) December 2010
(01) November 2010
(01) October 2010
(01) June 2010
(01) May 2010
(02) March 2010
(01) January 2010
(02) December 2009
(03) September 2009
(03) August 2009
(09) July 2009
(04) June 2009
(03) May 2009
(02) April 2009
(03) March 2009
(02) February 2009
(02) January 2009
(04) December 2008
(04) November 2008
(05) October 2008
(04) September 2008
(05) August 2008
(04) July 2008
(05) June 2008
(07) May 2008
(04) April 2008
(03) March 2008
(02) February 2008
(03) January 2008
(03) December 2007
(05) November 2007
(04) October 2007
(05) September 2007
(12) August 2007
(11) July 2007
(14) June 2007
(13) May 2007
(13) April 2007
(10) March 2007
(11) February 2007
(14) January 2007
(14) December 2006
(12) November 2006
(08) October 2006
(09) September 2006
(06) August 2006
(08) July 2006
(10) June 2006
(09) May 2006
(22) April 2006
(25) March 2006
(12) February 2006
(14) January 2006
(19) December 2005
(17) November 2005
(16) October 2005
(16) September 2005
(12) August 2005
(14) July 2005
(09) June 2005
(12) May 2005
(12) April 2005
(20) March 2005
(11) February 2005
(12) January 2005
(18) December 2004
(13) November 2004
(12) October 2004
(14) September 2004
(09) August 2004
(23) July 2004
(19) June 2004
(29) May 2004
(19) April 2004
(16) March 2004
(09) February 2004
(06) January 2004
(02) December 2003
(01) November 2003

Post Categories

.Net and C#
Android
Antispam
App. Development
Architecture
ASP.NET
Blogging
Deprecated Projects
Facebook Platform
Fun
Google
iOS
Javascript
Misc.
MSSQL
Music
My Games
Performance
Roller
Social Networks
Tools
Visual Studio
Web 2.0
WebServices

About Me

linkedin Profile
Recs
Who am I

My Sites

Billy Beet
x2line blogs